How to Turn Email Subscribers into Crypto-Paying Customers

Accepting cryptocurrency payments is a big step forward for any business. 

But how do you make sure your customers actually know they can pay with Bitcoin, Ethereum, stablecoins, or else? 

We’ve talked about several strategies before, such as social media and content marketing. However, email remains one of the highest-ROI and most effective marketing channels available.

In fact, 42% of marketers rate email as their most effective channel (far ahead of social media or search), according to Designmodo research. 

Moreover, half of consumers have purchased directly from an email – more than from social posts or ads.

With that said, here are some strategies to help you promote crypto payments through email campaigns, which should help inform your customers and, ultimately, boost sales.

1. Announce Your New Payment Option

Your first step is to let your customers know. Send a dedicated announcement email with a clear subject line like “We Now Accept Crypto”. Inside, highlight:

• The list of cryptocurrencies you accept.
• Why this benefits customers (fast, global, flexible).
• A CTA that encourages paying with crypto.

This type of campaign works best right after you enable crypto payments – it sets the stage and grabs attention.

2. Educate and Build Trust

Not every customer understands crypto payments. Use your email campaigns to answer questions and build confidence:

• Explain how crypto payments work.
• Show how easy it is to pay – include visuals like a checkout screenshot or QR code.
• Reassure subscribers about safety and reliability (mentioning your payment processor, helps).
• Add a short FAQ section for common concerns.

This approach reduces hesitation and helps more people feel comfortable trying it.

3. Offer Incentives for Paying with Crypto

Encourage adoption by rewarding customers who choose crypto:

• Limited-time discounts (e.g., “Save 10% when paying with crypto”).
• Exclusive crypto-only promotions.
• Loyalty points, cashback, or digital perks tied to crypto transactions.

This strategy works especially well for the first few months after launch, when you want to boost adoption rates.

4. Segment Your Audience

Different groups of customers care about different benefits of crypto payments. Email segmentation helps you highlight the right message for the right audience:

• Tech-savvy customers → Emphasize modern features like multi-network support.
• International buyers → Focus on avoiding currency conversion fees.
• High-value customers → Stress the security and reliability of stablecoin payments.

The more relevant the message, the higher your engagement and conversions.

5. Reinforce With Post-Purchase Emails

If someone pays with crypto, don’t let the experience end at checkout. A tailored follow-up email can strengthen loyalty:

• Thank them for paying with crypto.
• Confirm how quick and easy their payment was.
• Encourage to continue using crypto for payments.

This kind of reinforcement turns one-time users into repeat crypto customers.

6. Use Social Proof in Your Newsletters

Once you’ve had some traction, share the results:

• Highlight the growing number of people paying with crypto.
• Share testimonials or customer quotes about their experience.
• Position yourself as a forward-thinking, crypto-friendly brand.

Social proof creates momentum and makes crypto owners more likely to buy your product or service with crypto.

Final Thoughts

Accepting crypto payments is only the first step – promoting them effectively is what ensures real adoption. Email marketing gives you a direct line to your audience and allows you to explain, incentivize, and normalize paying with Bitcoin, Ethereum, stablecoins, and others.

By combining announcements, education, incentives, personalization, post-purchase flows, and social proof, you can make crypto payments a natural and appealing option for your customers.

Not a CoinGate client yet? Sign up.